Clipper Ship Nightingale

Jenny Lind Figurehead

March 1, 2008 Jenny Lind Figurehead Sotheby's Auction Update at bottom of the page

 

_____________________________

Dear Don,

Thank you for a wonderful Web site.

This information might be something for your site.

SUMMARY

The Nightingale, one of the world's best-known merchant ships, carried an exquisitely sculptured figurehead representing the vivacious songster Jenny Lind. The figurehead had a most adventurer career. It was there when the Nightingale took American pioneers to the Australian gold fields, it took part in the famous Tea Race from China to London, it carried 2,000 slaves in irons, and it saw service in the American Civil War.

____________________________

____________________________

The Nightingale ship paintings at the top of this page are by the Swedish marine artist Carl Hendel Friberg.

In the book; The American Built Clipper Ship 1850 - 1856 the Author William Crother refers to an article about the clipper ship Nightingale published in the Boston Daily Evening Traveller some time between December 23, 1850 and September 21, 1853.

It says: A finely carved figure of Jenny Lind, painted white, set off with gilded ornaments: in the right hand, which is extended, is a gilded bird, representing the Nightingale with half spread wings.

The figureheads left arm is a replacement for the original. Originally it was forward and upward. Its right arm is the original arm but it isn't anatomically correct. From the beginning it has also been forward but not as much as the left arm. It has got an altered position to achieve the correct angle to secure the arm up towards the chest - a much safer position.

The reconstruction made by laser scanning techniques - shows the Swedish Nightingale in her golden days urging the nightingale to fly out and sing to the world.

__________________________

_____________________________

Maritime Book Review

By Don Ross

Every clipper ship has a story and that of the Nightingale is most intriguing for she is forever linked to the Swedish Nightingale, Jenny Lind, the most remarkable singer of the clipper ship era. A figurehead of her likeness once graced the Nightingale's bow, and she spent a remarkable 42 years at sea, where she was abandoned in the North Atlantic sometime between March 17 and April 17, 1893 on a voyage between Liverpool and Halifax. But did the figurehead really go down with the ship? If not, what happened to it? Could this old "scarecrow" that turned up in a Swedish farmer's barn in 1994, a century later, that the author, an antiques dealer, chanced upon be that figurehead?

______________________________

______________________________

Karl-Eric Svärdskog, has done a remarkable job unravelling this mystery and sheds much light upon the history of the Nightingale and the clipper ship era - particularly where figureheads are concerned. By his own admission, "Two requisites for this task were a weakness for old wooden pieces combined with 'crazy furniture disease.'" Günter, a friend, shared Karl's interest in old furniture and one day in May, 1994 asked him: "Do you want to buy a scarecrow?" Günter had found it in the loft of a farmer's barn strewn with piles of junk, dust, and spiderwebs, where it had been for perhaps 100 years as the farmer explained, because it scared not only birds, but people. The farmer accepted Karl's bid, and Günter and his son picked it up in his old diesel fire truck and brought it back to his barn. The author's own words pick up the story from there.

____________________________

Günter

____________________________

Jenny Lind Figurehead

Displayed at Mystic Seaport

____________________________

Here we see the Jenny Lind figurehead on display in the same room with the eagle figurehead from Donald McKay's clipper ship the Great Republic, the only other clipper ship figurehead known to exist today.

_____________________________

__________________________

Jenny Lind Figurehead of the Clipper Ship Nightingale Auctioned off at Sotheby's.

__________________________

__________________________

Aftermath

ECS - An article appeared in the Antique Section of the January 4, 2008 edition of the New York Times about the upcoming auction to take place on January 19th at Sotheby's auction house in New York City. I e-mailed Karl and made plans to meet up with Karl at Sotheby's on Tuesday before the Saturday auction, as the Jenny Lind Figurehead was to be on display all that week.

The final chapter of the Jenny Lind figurehead saga was about to take place and Karl was filled with hopeful anticipation for the auction to come, but also anxiety for the Times article let on that there was a certain Massachusetts art dealer, Ryan Cooper, who stated for the article that in his opinion the figurehead was not the original figurehead of the clipper ship Nightingale, and expressed his doubts, even though the evidence that Karl so painstakingly presents here stands up to the closest scrutiny in the eyes of the National Geographic Magazine, the experts of the Antique Road Show, as well as with eminent maritime historians of the Portsmouth Marine Society, the Mystic Seaport, and the South Street Seaport Museum.

I have read Karl's book and have personally taken a very long hard look at the evidence, and after knowing Karl and being personally acquainted with Jenny these past three years and four months, that there is no doubt in my mind that this figurehead is, indeed, the long-lost figurehead of the clipper ship Nightingale. - Don Ross - ECS

_________________________

__________________________

Dear Donald,
In the time span of six years The Jenny Lind/Nightingale figurehead stood exhibited at several leading American Maritime museums. One can ask why experts in the field who might have questioned “Jenny’s” origin never came forward during all these years. Why didn’t they organize a summit to discuss “Jenny’s” provenance and once and for all made up their mind in this case? No museum of maritime heritage or organization like the Maritime Heritage Conference indicated any interest in a hearing giving me a chance to present my scientific research on the matter.
Assume I’d been given a possibility to present my methods of research with all circumstantial evidence gathered to exclude possibilities, ship by ship, that “Jenny” was born elsewhere than in America. A summit of experts could have come to a consensus once and for all. Instead a dealer in maritime artifacts with a questionable agenda enters the scene and acts like a spokesman to all scientists of USA regarding maritime history. This is strong compared to how we deal with things like this in the old world.
The American people should have a possibility to take part of “Jenny’s” exciting story. During the two weeks the original and copy of “Jenny” stood side by side at Sotheby’s I realized to the full extent what an intriguing history lesson “Jenny” stands for. Spectators strolling by stopped at the monitor where a DVD-Video showed a brief documentary while 27 stills were presented in sequins on the opposite wall. They seemed to be sucked in to the intriguing story.
Hopefully the new owner of “Jenny” will put her on show sometime in the future to let interested citizens enjoy her as a part of their history. A documentary by, for example, History Channel would certainly make an impact.
The history of Jenny Lind as a figurehead on the extreme American Clipper Nightingale belongs to the American people and I feel sadness in my heart when none of the American Maritime Museums put any interest in buying her. Amazing, when in retrospect, I’ve been in contact with them all.
The remaining $90 000 after deductions from Sotheby’s equal to me a moderate net after tax that I’d easily could top as sitting in front of a school class as a teacher a few days of the week, during this fourteen years. If this “Jenny business” was organized to be a hoax, this fourteen years of struggle would be an insult to my intelligence to set it off.
All expenses regarding “Jenny," monetary and privately, came from my own pocket and battered my conscience, knowing my family from time to time was set aside. Although I believed that if I did my job thoroughly, there would be a reward in the end to make up for lost time and living standard.
In the end I never reached the point of breakeven. Tens of thousands hours have been spent on research in the American People’s history for the American People. Today it all seems like a meaningless deed as nobody of weight really cared.
My compensation will forever be all these wonderful years with “Jenny." I tried to regain her former status as one of a kind and she made me travel to exciting places, meeting exciting people, writing two books on the subject which filled me with satisfaction knowing I’d solved an impossible “cold case” from our history.
Due time I will come to rest with the feeling of being looted. For some time I had the privileges to own and resurrect a wonderful piece of art. Bad though “Jenny” was to be killed by a vindictive antique dealer.
Never the less, I know that the future will prove me right.

Ps/ If possible, it would be nice if you put in a link to my website.

www.swedishnightingale.com

All best

Karl

__________________________

_________________________

 

____________________________

_______________________________

PROVENANCE FOR THE JENNY LIND FIGUREHEAD FROM THE NIGHTINGALE:

1851 - Likely carved by John W. Mason in his studio at 46 Commercial Street, Boston.

1885-86 - Removed from the Nightingale during repairs on the ship in Norway.

1994 - Discovered in a barn in Sweden.

1996 - Unveiled by the King of Sweden Carl XVI Gustaf at the National Museum of Fine Arts in Stockholm. On Stage at the Stockholm Concert Hall in connection with a Jenny Lind Concert.

1997 - Symbol for the Cutty Sark Tall Ships Races in Gothenburg.

1998 - Presented in the May issue of National Geographic Magazine.

2001 - June 16 on stage during a Jenny Lind concert at Portsmouth Music hall to mark 150th anniversary of the Nightingale. Summer guest at the Portsmouth Athenaeum Reading room.

My book Jenny Lind and the Clipper Nightingale figurehead was published by the Portsmouth Marine Society.

2002 - 2005 - On exhibit in the Wendell Building at Mystic Seaport Museum.

____________________________

___________________________

As you know, very few actual parts remain from the aproximately 500 built American clipper ships. The Nightingale figurehead is, together with the eagle from the Great Republic, the only saved figure from an extreme clipper ship.

From medium clippers four figureheads exist and two are saved from half clippers.

A binnacle boy remains from the N. B. Palmer at the Museum of the City of New York.

A piece of the bow exists from the Snow Squall at the Maine Maritime Museum.

A shipbell from Noonday is saved at San Francisco Maritime National Park.

The deckhouse and the railing fom the Nightingale have survived in Kragerö in Norway.

Paul Johnston (Smithsonian), Daniel Finamore (Peabody), and Revell Car (former President for Mystic Seaport) believe that Jenny is the only saved figurehead from a slaver.

My evidence for the authenticity of this long-lost figurehead, as a Mason is very strong. Revell Car says that John W. Mason is the likely suspect in the mystery of who carved Jenny. Mason is considered by many the foremost American sculptor of his time.

___________________________

Directory

____________________________

The Meeting I Shall Never Forget

When I pushed open the heavy door to Günter's barn, I saw a flickering candle flame. Günter came forward out of the darkness with a pair of white cloth gloves, which he handed me. "Put these on. I've just finished making a wreath out of wildflowers." Gloves and wildflowers? What was happening to him?

Then, in the faint candlelight, I got my first glimpse of what presumably was the scarecrow. It was supported on trestle stands and was hidden under a thin blanket. Music streamed from loudspeakers; Günter had found a music cassette the week before in the garbage-Mozart's Requiem. The covered figure reminded me of something I had seen exhibited at the Livrustkammaren [the Royal Armory] in Stockholm-the coronation armor of Gustaf II Adolf [Swedish hero king], . . . . The flower wreath rested on the scarecrow's corresponding body part. I was well aware of Günter's strange sense of humor, but this exceeded my expectations. He lit even more candles and turned up the music.

Hesitantly I walked toward the figure. With my gloved hand, I carefully tugged at the cover. What was I going to see? An ugly, grinning old man made of wood, with hair made of straw? Slowly, slowly I began to unveil the scarecrow.

The first thing I saw was the beautifully sculpted hair, then the forehead, eyes, nose, mouth, and chin. The experience was intense and unreal. I felt my knees shaking.

I whispered, "What is this? Am I dreaming? Together Günter and I used all our strength to lift the figure to a standing position. Layers of spiderwebs and dirt covered the wooden lady. What emerged from history's darkness looked like a saint. As we stood at attention in front of her, the light from the flickering candles and the powerful music created a sacred atmosphere. Everything else around us ceased to exist. The world stood still as questions whirled in my head. Who are you? Who made you? Where did you come from?

____________________________

____________________________

__________________________

__________________________

_________________________

What happened to the “Jenny Lind” Nightingale Clipper Ship Figurehead at Sotheby´s?

The background
 After thirteen years of painstakingly time and money consuming efforts, I, Karl-Eric Svardskog from Gothenburg, Sweden, felt that I’d done my homework. My conscience was clear when I stated that the figurehead presented by me was “Jenny Lind” from the former extreme clipper Nightingale. When I began my investigation in “Jenny’s” past in 1994 I involved scholars in maritime archaeology in order to establish a scientific platform for “Jenny."  As time went by Sweden and Scandinavia was rolled out as being “Jenny’s” land of origin and I extended my search to England and then America. In my book “Jenny Lind and the Clipper Nightingale Figurehead," 2001, everyone can follow my deeds up to this time. No stone was left unturned when converting hypothesis so close to evidence as is possible to man.

__________________________

__________________________

In 2007 I decided to put the unique Jenny Lind/Nightingale figurehead up for auction at Sotheby’s New York branch. Finally the only one of two saved figureheads from the extreme American clipper ship era was going home.
I felt in my heart that I had a good case and that many interested buyers would come forward to bid for Jenny - a once in a lifetime piece of American heritage.

The Setup
At Sotheby’s “Jenny” got a high ranking in the field of Important Americana and was presented on the cover and on ten pages in the catalogue including a summary of  Revell Carr (former President for the Mystic Seaport Museum). The estimate $100.000 - $150.000 was put on Jenny by Nancy Druckman (in charge of the American Folk Art department at Sotheby’s) a year ago. I thought it was to low but Nancy said that she wanted to keep it low since she knew it would tempt more customers. In my opinion it was a dangerous gambling with my money. Even if Nancy had been in the auction business for more than 30 years and knew the trade better than anyone - it was impossible for her to foresee everything that could go wrong. For example that my strong case for the figurehead’s identity was to be questioned because of Cooper’s invented statements in the New York Times - the national newspaper of record.

In an article on “Jenny” by Wendy Moonan in N.Y.T. January 4, 2008, two weeks before the auction, antiques dealer Ryan Cooper expressed his allegation of the Jenny Lind figurehead. Mr Cooper was allowed to express his doubts without presenting any facts. He said: "In my opinion it is not the original figurehead from the Nightingale. If it was from the Nightingale, and in my opinion that's a real stretch,it has to be a replacement. It has no correspondence to American figureheads at all. The carving is typically Scandinavian."
Nancy Druckman was given the opportunity to response to Cooper’s allegation in a few lines but the damage was already done.

On January 6, I sent an e-mail to Nancy Druckman to ask if she considered a more detailed response to the allegation of Ryan Cooper. She said that in cases like this it better to leave things be.

Unfortunately, in this case, she was terribly wrong. Nancy didn’t realise that figurehead collectors and dealers belong to a very small and easily affected society.
What Mr Cooper didn’t say in the article was that an antique dealer friend of his failed to buy Jenny from me in Gothenburg in 1995. This friend of Mr. Cooper's said in a letter from 07/17-95. “The figurehead of the Nightingale, I do believe it to be authentic. My client would be very interested in acquiring it for the Maine Maritime Museum at a fair price. We are now and will remain ready to purchase the figurehead at a reasonable figure…”

Another thing Mr Cooper didn’t say was that he and his friend contacted Peter Randall – publisher for the Portsmouth Marine Society – in December 2000 to ask him to cancel the project with the Nightingale figurehead book.
In a mail on December 26, 2000 Peter Randal stated; I’m beginning to get comments from both Mr. Cooper and his friend. They are now saying that they believe the figurehead is not American and that it is of European origin. I think it is interesting that this person wrote that the figurehead is authentic when he wanted to buy it and had seen it in person: since he didn’t buy it, now he changes his mind.”
From this point and on the Jenny Lind/Nightingale Figurehead seemed to be doomed.

__________________________

___________________________

Directory

___________________________

ECS - We are saddened by this murky, unsettling, and unjust aftermath of the clipper ship Nightingale Jenny Lind Figurehead saga, and wish that things had come out differently for Karl for his noble efforts. So much of our American clipper ship history has been lost for so many years and when something as precious as a genuine figurehead from a clipper ship turns up like this, we wonder why maritime historians on this side of the pond could not do more to claim it as our own, a national treasure, purchase it at its true value, and display it in an honored permanent collection in an American maritime museum.

___________

 

____________________________

_____________________________

The Nightingale's Jenny Lind is one of the most historically important American figureheads. It will fascinate collectors interested in maritime history and American folk art, but furthermore people interested in - Jenny Lind-memorabilia - items from the slave trade, and from the Civil War.

During the last year I have been giving talks on the figurehead at several museums in Sweden.

The figure is a masterpiece and the only Mason Carving known to survive.

My hope for the future is that the Jenny Lind figurehead will be bought by a philanthropist, institution, or corporation and then be donated to a museum. At a public display it can contribute to educational efforts about Jenny Lind, the work of John Mason, and the clipper ship era.

_____________________________

_____________________________

In January 2006 the South Street Seaport Museum will open an exhibition on Clipper Ships and the Nightingale figure. You are welcome to visit the old lady. She looks quite a bit better in the wood, so to speak, than in photos.

I attach some photos of the figure and a photo of one of the Nightingale's deckhouse still standing on an island outside Kragerö in Norway.

 

Sincerely,

Karl Eric Svärdskog

______________________________

_____________________________

ECS - Karl can be e-mailed at: k_e_svardskog@hotmail.com.

For more information concerning the book: Jenny Lind - and the Clipper Nightingale Figurehead

Portsmouth Marine Society

Box 147

Portsmouth, NH 03802

www.perpublisher.com/pms27.html

______________________________

And so begins the hunt for information that takes the author on his quest to unravel the mystery that leads him to believe that the scarecrow is, indeed, the Jenny Lind figurehead of the clipper ship Nightingale. Along the way Karl falls under the enchanting spell of the legend of Jenny Lind and opera, even though he is happily married to his wife, Elisabeth. Karl captures the "Jenny Lind Fever" in grand style for 30 pages with lots of pictures in chapter two.

Karl was also encouraged by the uncovered fact that Kragerø in southern Norway was the Nightingale's home harbor during her last twenty years at sea. One of her deckhouses was preserved on the island of Kirkeholmen, outside Kragerø. The Scandinavian marine museums yield more clues. The research-quest stirs up interest among his acquaintences and the Scandinavian public, and the research trails lead in numerous directions. Many adventures follow as Karl tries to put all the missing pieces of the puzzle together on this personal odyssey that has become an obsession and the biggest event of his life. This is Karl's tale to tell, and the reader soon becomes swept up in the enthusiasm of the quest.

____________________________

.____________________________

One trail leads to all the books about the American clipper ship era that Karl can lay his hands on in his attempt to ferret out all the Nightingale information he can, and he puts together a very detailed history of the clipper Nightingale - certainly one of the most interesting histories of the clipper ship era. I, for one, learned a few things about this clipper that I didn't know before.

His adventurous, scholarly quest takes him to the United States to visit all the major New England maritime museums, Boston, New York City, Wilmington, Delaware, and Washington D.C. And his further research pays off as more pieces of the puzzle come together. In the authors words, "The circle closes." At long last the credibility of the quest begins to sink in and be taken seriously by many of the maritime history museum establishment folks on this side of the pond, for Karl has built a most convincing case after four long years of hard work. It's all here in this book and any enthusiast of the clipper ship era will find it a very good read, I certainly did.

An interesting Appendix chapter is included: "Nightingale" A Clipper Ship and Her Commander, by Frank Jewett Mather, M. A., that originally appeared in The Atlantic Monthly, November 1904. This is an exciting first-hand account of the Nightingale and her commander, Samuel W. Mather, by his son, about a voyage in 1853 from New York to Melbourne, Australia, and then on to Hong Kong, Shanghai, Whampoa, and London.

Karl flew back to the USA in September 2005 for another visit to pick up the Jenny Lind figurehead at the Mystic Seaport Museum to take her down to the South Street Seaport Museum, where she will be on display for a while. Karl invited me to meet up with him at the museum when he arrived, to be there when the figurehead was taken out of her packing crate, and get the chance to meet "Jenny."

I went down to New York City that day to the museum and met Karl, along with Jeff Remling, Director of Operations and Curator of Collections, and after a pleasant lunch, assisted them in uncrating the Jenny Lind figurehead and standing her up in the gallery. Upon a close inspection, there is no doubt in my mind that this is, indeed, the long-lost figurehead of the clipper ship Nightingale, and I stood there in awe with the awareness that Jenny had finally arrived back in the port city that she had departed from 152 years ago on May 19, 1853, juxtaposed to the bow of the Nightingale, bound for Australia, China, and London at the height of the clipper ship era. A quiver of excitement ran through me as I gazed upon Jenny for the first time and certainly understood why Karl had gone on this quest. I urge everyone to visit the South Street Seaport Museum and take a look at the Jenny Lind figurehead for yourselves, see some of the magnificient clipper ship paintings on the gallery walls, including those of James Buttersworth and John Stobart, and let your imaginations take you back to the golden age of sail. For maritime history comes alive at the
South Street Seaport Museum.

southstreetseaportmuseum.org

__________________________

__________________________

A Lethal Blow
The days before the auction I had a bad feeling that something tricky was going on.
I suggested Nancy Druckman that we should withdraw Jenny from the sale, but she said that it was not possible.
Habitual potential buyers became suspicious to Jenny because of Ryan Coopers statement in the New York Times. 
Curators and collectors were since long affected by Ryan Cooper’s of many years cocksure statements that Jenny was carved in Europe.
However, it was no big deal for an experienced American Folk Art dealer to agree to what Revell Carr’s says in the text in Sotheby’s catalogue: Jenny was an American “once in a lifetime piece”.

__________________________

The conspiracy
As Jenny came up for sale I felt as lonely as a sheep in front of a group of hungry wolfs. One customer was bidding in the room and one was on the phone. Those folk art dealers who thought that it was the authentic figurehead from the Nightingale stood silent. In my opinion interested dealers had an agreement to not interfere with the sale - to keep the hammer price down and to reduce the buyer's premium. An invaluable figurehead went for the absurd low reserve of  $100,000. Not one single paddle against the winning bid was seen from dealers in the room. As the gavel fell, the figurehead of Jenny Lind, attributed to John Mason, one of America’s most famous carvers, from the legendary clipper Nightingale was given away for about the same price as what a circus wagon figure without face and hands cost in an antiques shop.  
I don’t know who bought Jenny but it is obvious that he got her without a fight and at a “fair price."

__________________________

__________________________

The Aftermath
As one can understand there is a very logical sequence of events that would explain why Ryan Cooper made his best to hurt the Jenny Lind figurehead before the auction. His opinion regarding ”Jenny” in the New York Times had a devastating effect. I got many comments during the presale as; ”Is she really American?"
During the sale almost no one in the room showed serious interest in Jenny. I couldn´t figure out why. After the sale I felt numb and sought for an explanation. I couldn’t figure out why this N.Y.T. article, all of a sudden, becomes the truth and nothing but the truth and so mysteriously found its way to every ones eyes and minds.  
How come that anybody with the slightest interest in “Jenny” with ample possibilities to search for neutral opinions on the subject and at any time could find everything regarding “Jennys” whereabouts, for example, on my web-site www.swedishnightingale.com plus links, seemed to oversee this opportunity to make up their minds of their own?

How come that Mr Ryan Cooper of Massachusetts with his opinion overcame experts like
Harry Aldern (executing wood identification reporter), the Keno brothers (experts at the Antiques Road Show), Alan Miller and Philip Bradley (Americas most established experts in the fields of New England furniture and folk art), Revell Carr (former President for the Mystic Seaport Museum) and Nancy Druckman. All of these experts agree to that there is no doubt that the Jenny Lind figurehead is an American piece. They all stand behind the following summary by Revell Carr; 
“The wood identification report (Harry Alden Identification Service) is a good confirmation that this is an American piece. With the identification as Pinus Strobus (Eastern White Pine), and with that wood being the wood of choice for New England carvers, I think there is little doubt that this is American in origin. I believe we can dismiss the issue of Eastern White Pine having been shipped to England in abundance during colonial times for use as masts and that some of that wood might have been “re-cycled” into 19th century carvings. As  Harry Alden says, if it was done, it would probably have been for small items, since it would have been difficult to get a large enough, undamaged piece for a figurehead. Other more easily acquried and suitable wood would have been available to and preferable for English or European carvers”.
According to curator Manne Dunge at Karlskrona Maritime Museum in Sweden there are no  known Scandinavian figureheads carved from Eastern White Pine. Scandinavian carvers used Swedish Pine or oak. 

Without doubt we can state that Mr Cooper's allegation of the Jenny Lind figurehead in the N.Y.T. hurt the piece irreparably. It hurt Revell Carr, Nancy Druckman and Sotheby’s, let alone myself.

First weekday after the auction I visited Nancy Druckman at Sotheby’s.
She said the usual, that she was sorry but things like this happen at auctions. A risk you have to take. I asked her to read through a written statement of my thoughts.
She told me to come back after an hour.
When I came back she said: We have decided to do something very unusual for Sotheby’s. We have decided to ask the buyer if he would like to give Jenny back.

___________________________

___________________________